Why I'm Comparing a 1986 and a 1999 Lincoln Continental

Most people don't compare two cars that far apart. I get that. But at work I don't really have a choice. We keep two Lincoln Continentals in the company garage—a 1986 and a 1999—both tied to the founders. I'm the office administrator, which in a 60-person company means I'm also the unofficial fleet manager. I place somewhere between 60 and 80 orders a year across eight or nine vendors, and roughly $18,000 of that spend is vehicle-related.

When I took this over in 2020, I assumed tires were tires. Two years in, I'd learned that the 1986 and the 1999 are basically unrelated machines with unrelated wheel and tire demands. So this is the comparison I wish someone had handed me—not "which car is better," but "how do you buy tires for each one without wasting money or annoying the people who actually drive them."

I'm going to run the same four angles on both cars: size and availability, cost, age and safety, and whether the Continental brand itself matters here. Then I'll tell you which one I treat differently, and why.

Dimension 1: Tire Size and Availability

Here's the thing: the 1986 is the harder of the two, and it's not close.

The 1986 Continental came out of an era of taller sidewalls and smaller wheel diameters. That's lovely for ride comfort and miserable for buying tires in 2025, because that whole segment has shrunk. Walk into a chain tire store and you get a polite "let me check availability" that sounds a lot like "we don't stock that." The size still exists, but you may be choosing between two or three options instead of twenty.

The 1999 is the easier one. It ran a more common 16-inch fitment that's still well supported. When I priced availability in that size across four online retailers in early 2025, every one of them returned six or seven name-brand options, plus a couple of budget lines. The selection isn't as deep as it would be for a modern sedan. But it's real.

Verdict: the 1999 is the simpler procurement problem. The 1986 needs planning—call ahead, confirm lead time, and don't assume you can walk in on a Saturday and roll out the same afternoon.

One more thing worth saying out loud: the size on the door placard is a starting point, not gospel. Older cars get modified. A previous owner may have swapped wheels off a different Ford. I learned that one the expensive way on a 1986—the placard said one size, the car was wearing another, and I didn't look. Really, I should have just looked at the tire that was already on it.

Dimension 2: Cost Per Tire

Counterintuitive result here: the harder-to-find 1986 tire is not necessarily the more expensive one. It's often cheaper per unit—there's just less choice and less room to trade up or down.

When I priced both in January 2025:

  • 1986 size, mid-tier all-season: roughly $85–$130 per tire, mounted and balanced. Budget lines exist below that range, but I've stopped buying bottom-tier for these cars after a bad experience (more on that below).
  • 1999 size, comparable mid-tier touring: roughly $120–$180 per tire, mounted and balanced. Name-brand options push toward the top of that range or above it.

So the 1986 wins on price and loses on basically everything else. If budget were the only variable, the 1986 would be the easy call. It isn't.

Which brings me to the part most tire articles skip entirely.

Dimension 3: Age, Safety, and the DOT Code Nobody Checks

This is the one that surprised me, and it's the one I now check first on both cars.

Here's something vendors won't tell you: a car that gets driven 2,000 miles a year will usually wear out its tires by age long before it wears them out by tread. The rubber hardens, cracks at the sidewall, and loses grip—even when the tread still looks perfectly fine. On a low-mileage classic, that's the normal case, not the exception.

The manufacture date is printed on the tire. Per the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), every tire sold in the U.S. carries a DOT Tire Identification Number on the sidewall, and the last four digits give the week and year of manufacture. "3520" means the 35th week of 2020. Anything over six years old deserves a hard look, and ten years is roughly where I stop trusting it for anything above parking-lot speeds.

Here's the part that caught me off guard. Our 1999 had a set of tires that looked outstanding—deep tread, no obvious cracking. Two of them were stamped from 2011. That's fourteen years old. The car had barely been driven, which is exactly why nobody had thought about it. Tread depth is a terrible proxy for tire health on a car that sits.

So my process changed. Before anything else, I read the DOT code on all four tires of both cars. If a car is going out on a highway and the tires are past six or seven years, they get replaced regardless of tread. That's not a sales pitch—it's the cheapest insurance I buy all year.

Verdict: the 1986 tends to be the bigger risk here, not because it's a worse car, but because the tires on it are more likely to be old. They're harder to source, so people put it off. And then it sits another two years.

Dimension 4: Does the Continental Brand Actually Matter?

This is where I'll be honest: the badge on the sidewall mattered less than I expected, and the spec sheet mattered more.

For the 1999, a Continental-brand touring tire is a genuinely good fit. That car was built for highway comfort, and a quiet, smooth-riding tire matches what it's meant to do. I've put Continental tires on it and been happy. But I'm not going to pretend it's the only acceptable choice—there are two or three other brands that do the same job at a similar price, and I've bought them when the Continental wasn't in stock.

For the 1986, I care less about the brand and more about the load rating and the sidewall construction. That car's original equipment expectations were built around tire technology that simply doesn't exist anymore, so you're making a judgment call no matter what name is on it.

Wait, let me back up for a second. The reason spec matters more than brand on an old car is that you're not choosing from the manufacturer's curated list anymore. You're choosing from whatever still exists in that size. Once you've filtered by size, load index, and speed rating, you're typically down to a handful of options anyway. Brand is the last filter, not the first.

That was the reversal in my own thinking, honestly. I came into this assuming brand-first, because that's how I buy everything else. Now I go size, then load, then age, then brand. The brand decisions get a lot easier at the end.

So Which One Would I Treat Differently?

They're different buying problems, so they get different treatment.

If you're maintaining the 1999: this is the easier one. Find the correct size from the door placard, cross-check the load index, filter for a reputable touring tire, and buy. Continental is a sound pick; so are a couple of competitors. Watch the DOT date on whatever ships—if the warehouse sends you a set that was made four years ago, ask for a fresher set. Some sellers will do it. The ones that won't tell you something.

If you're maintaining the 1986: plan two weeks out, not two days. Call and confirm stock before you order, not after. Expect fewer choices, and don't assume you can trade up to something better just by paying more—the ceiling is set by what's still manufactured in that size. And check the DOT code the moment the tires arrive, before anyone mounts them.

One thing that's the same for both: don't skip the date code. I know I've said it three times now. That's on purpose. It's the single most common failure I've seen on low-mileage cars, and no salesperson is going to bring it up unprompted.

Look, none of this is glamorous. But if you're the person who has to make the call, "buy the right size and check how old it is" will get you further than any brand loyalty will.

Parker Hannifin Engineering Desk

Technical notes for energy and mining equipment specification, commissioning, and lifecycle planning.

Previous: Buying a Derrick: Three Buyer Scenarios, Three Different Answers (And Why the Sticker Price Lies) Next: Continental Sourcing Checklist: 7 Steps Before You Approve Another Order